If you're gonna get an active sub i'd stay away from Mackie because their product reliability is very poor these days. Ever since Greg Mackie sold the company to Loud Technologies, it's gone down hill and now the company in my and a lot of other people's opinions who i've talked to, is not a hell of a lot more reliable than Behringer. Loud Technologies moved manufacturing to China and then started using cheap quality parts in the Mackie equipment. I spoke to a shop about 3 months ago who said they had a whole bunch of Mackie SRM1801 subs come back in for repair because every single one failed. Then on youtube i've spoken to numerous people who've had repair after repair after repair. On other forums i've spoken to various people who've had enough because they've spent a lot of money on Mackie gear only for it to fail. My friend bought 2 Mackie HD1531 cabs and they failed on him. He had them repaired and they failed again during a gig that time. That was it, game over, gig over. That really P****d him off because he was lucky people at thge gig understood, you never know whether your gear failing could ruin your reputation.
Anyway, the best sub i've heard for it's price is the JBL PRX618S-XLF. It's quite expensive but it's an excellent sub and has JBL's fantastic 2268 driver in it, which is the same driver JBL use in their mighty SRX and VRX series subs. The RCF Art905AS is a great sub but the JBL goes down lower into the frequency response so if it were me, i'd personally go for the JBL.
mjmac,
The 130db spl output figure is a Peak spl rating, not continuous, so there's no way you'd actually get 130db out of it. Most specs for spl output are calculated, and calculated spl specs are wildly inaccurate. Mackie demonstrated this when they released their HD series cabs and subs. They measured the REAL maximum spl output of their cabs and subs alongside competitors and the REAL spl output figures wer as much as 14db lower than the calculated specs. Generally, if you take about 8-12db off the calculated Peak spl spec of a cab or sub it'll give you a good idea of how much spl you'll REALLY get. Like I say, Mackie measured their HD series cabs and subs, and also a competitors too. The Mackie HD1531 for example has a rated calculated spl output spec of 135db Peak, but when Mackie measured it's maximum spl output they saw a reading of 126db at the onset of clipping. This means that 126db is the REAL maximum spl output of that specific cab and shows you how inaccurate calculated spl specs are. Have a look here :
http://www.mackie.com/products/hdseries/pdf/HD_REAL_SPL.pdfI did some tests myself on my JBL MRX515 cab which has a calculated Peak spl of 130db, and I measured the cab's maximum spl output, C weighted and in full space and saw a reading of 122dbc. That once again shows you that calculated spl specs can't be trusted. The reason why manufacturers use them is because calculated specs are a perfect way for the manufacturer's marketing department to make their speakers look louder (on paper) than other speakers.